‘Sometimes you just have to put up with things’: Kalk Bay – Muizenberg Main Road Cape Town #missed opportunity

There’s something of the ‘prodigal son’ in Cape Town’s planning for utility cycling: the impacts of climate change, declining urban quality, and a high regard for international best practice, have seen the city begin to beckon drivers from their vehicles with alternative infrastructure.

But the cyclist who has kept the pedals turning all along is left behind.

Take Muizenberg/Kalk Bay main road, for example. One of Cape Town’s most popular and scenic roads, it has been in continual use for more than 200 years, and was by 2006 in need of major repairs due to the weight of 19 000 vehicles travelling it daily.

The road is also one of the most popular with recreational and utility cyclists – it is one of only three routes connecting the south peninsula to the southern suburbs. The other two are the steep mountain passes of Ou Kaapse Weg and Boyes Drive (both with gradients of 7% in places).

It is a vital commuter route, albeit narrow and heavily congested with on-street parking on either side of the road. It was earmarked for bicycle infrastructure as part of the City’s Velo-Mondial award-winning (2007) Bicycle Master Plan. Transport engineers prepared a concept plan for the road upgrade, including ‘excess land’ from the rail reserve (owned by state entity Transnet) to widen the road and include a narrow (1.3m) bicycle lane. However, bicycle lanes were not included on the final plans, and have as a result not been implemented.

The local authority cited lack of road space, no evident need nor sufficient request for bicycle lanes, and a budget for upgrade only (not capacity improvement) as the reason. However, cycling is now safer, says the City, as the road camber is flatter, and the drainage channel is less steep, so ‘cyclists can now ride almost on the channel edge [ie, the gutter].’

Public participation meetings were advertised in the local and neighbourhood press and radio, as well as with mail drops and posters. Interested and affected residents also commented on the plans by email. But Cape Town’s Pedal Power Association (South Africa’s largest recreational and racing cycling club with 15 000 members), among the 400 interested and affected parties on the City’s, says that it did not have an opportunity to comment.

Weekday mornings and evenings see approximately 30-40 utility cyclists travel this narrow stretch of road, a number which the City of Cape Town regards as “very few’. Interviews with these commuters points to perhaps 10% of them living within the public participation ‘catchment’ area; most live some 12-20 km beyond the area in question, and traverse this route on their way to work. When questioned, they were not aware of public participation opportunities, and are not listed as interested and affected parties.

AJ, 50, who works as a gardener and has been commuting by bicycle for four years along this road. He said the road was not safe for cycling, but ‘I save money when I travel on my bicycle.” He said he had narrowly escaped being knocked over by a car twice last year alone. ‘With bicycle lanes it could have been much better,” said January. ‘Sometimes I get so frustrated I just turn back for home. They are fixing the pipes and parking but they don’t provide for bicycles. Why must we come short,’ he asked. Harbour worker

HS, 67, who had been cycling on and off for eight years, said that once the roadworks were finished it was going to be “OK” for motorists, although it was still going to be difficult for cyclists. ‘Sometimes you just have to put up with things,’ he said.

To date [May 2011], the road upgrade has cost ZAR 100-million in public funds.

Extract (c) Gail Jennings: SOUTH AFRICAN CITY STUDIES CONFERENCE: 7-9 SEPTEMBER 2011 Cities for two wheels: rethinking bicycle planning for the rapidly urbanising context



GoMetro, Metrorail’s mobile info service, looks back on its first 30 days in action

Thirty days ago, as part of Metrorail’s “Programme of Action” initiative, Metrorail Western Cape partnered with South African technology start-up company, mobi.lity, to launch Go Metro – a digital resource for commuters to have more control in their journey when travelling on Metrorail trains in the Western Cape. The first month has seen the mobi-site […]

Giving infrastructure projects a green rating: how to design ‘green’ from the inside out

As we face significant challenges issues such as climate change and global warning, it is clear that the engineering profession has a significant part to play in influencing the future of our planet. Whatever we may think about environmental responsibility, we can be sure of this: that we all need, and will continue to need, […]

Fuel-cell cargo bike could power your lights and TV too

Locally designed hydrogen-powered tricycle – named ‘A hi Fambeni’, Xitsonga for ‘Let’s go’ – has attracted much attention since its 2010 launch in South Africa as a sustainably powered goods-to-market vehicle for rural areas. It’s also an entry into the international SMART Mobility EnterPrize competition, which aims to identify existing and emerging sustainable mobility business […]


  1. I live in Muizenberg and I ride to Kalk Bay pretty often!
    I’ve seen stacks of people riding that road for just plain fun and to get out as it is an amazing little easy ride. Lots of families as well.
    On weekends however there are waaaaaay more than 40-50 riders! I’d say easily around 200-300 if not more would go through there! The fact the city didn’t take this into account when they were doing their ridiculous road works which are STILL not finished around 6 years later, is crazy??
    A small bicycle lane would be brilliant here with some small lane separators.

    I think this would only encourage even more people to get out and ride.

  2. I think they must incorporate a lane even if it is part of the pedestrian walkway.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: